If you’re exploring affordable roofing options for your home and find yourself caught between price, durability, and aesthetics, you’re not alone. Homeowners often feel stuck when comparing materials, trying to figure out which roof will protect their house without breaking the bank. And with so many choices—metal, tile, synthetic—it’s easy to get overwhelmed.
But there’s one option that continues to stand out year after year: asphalt shingles. They’ve been the go-to for American homes for decades. But are they still the right fit for your roof today? Let’s take a closer look at the asphalt shingles pros and cons, including the benefits of asphalt shingles, potential drawbacks asphalt shingles may have, and how they stack up in an asphalt roofing comparison.
Why Homeowners in Eugene Are Drawn to Asphalt Shingles
Before we dive into the good and the not-so-good, let’s address the key reasons asphalt shingles remain one of the most popular roofing materials—not just in Oregon, but across the country.
Affordability and Accessibility
Asphalt shingles are widely available and cost-effective. In terms of affordable roofing options, they’re hard to beat. Whether you’re a new homeowner or planning a long-term upgrade, asphalt shingles fit most budgets while still delivering dependable performance.
Trusted Performance in Local Weather
Eugene’s weather throws a lot at a roof—wind-driven rain, occasional hail, and consistent damp conditions. Asphalt shingles, especially premium architectural types like IKO Dynasty, handle these challenges well. With proper installation, they provide solid protection for 25+ years.
The Benefits of Asphalt Shingles
Let’s start with the positives—because there are many. From design versatility to reliable protection, asphalt shingles check a lot of boxes.
Wide Variety of Styles and Colors
One of the biggest benefits of asphalt shingles is their ability to match almost any home design. You can choose from bold colors, dimensional looks, and even luxury options that mimic slate or shake.
At NW Roofing and Siding Pros, we install IKO Armourshake, Royal Estate, and Crown Slate—all of which offer a more refined look for those who want curb appeal with the reliability of shingle roofing.
Quick and Efficient Installation
Compared to metal or tile, asphalt shingles are much faster to install. This minimizes labor costs and shortens the disruption to your routine. A well-planned asphalt shingle installation can be completed in just a few days, weather permitting.
Impact-Resistant Options Available
If wind or hail is a concern, don’t worry—today’s shingles aren’t what they used to be. NW Roofing and Siding Pros offers IKO Nordic shingles, which are rated for impact resistance and come with a 130-mph wind warranty. These shingles have reinforced nail zones and a durable build that stands up to Eugene’s gusty conditions.
Easier to Repair and Replace
Another benefit of asphalt shingles is their modular nature. If a storm causes damage to a few shingles, repairs are straightforward and budget-friendly. That’s a big plus for homeowners who value long-term maintenance flexibility.
The Drawbacks of Asphalt Shingles
Of course, no material is perfect. To make a well-rounded decision, you should know the drawbacks asphalt shingles can come with. That way, you’ll know what to watch for and how to extend your roof’s lifespan.
Shorter Lifespan Than Some Premium Materials
When compared to standing-seam metal or synthetic tile roofing, asphalt shingles generally don’t last as long. While architectural and luxury lines can stretch to 30 years with proper care, other roofing types can easily push 40 to 70 years.
However, considering their lower upfront cost, the value equation often still tips in asphalt’s favor—especially when installed correctly by certified contractors like NW Roofing and Siding Pros.
Vulnerability to Algae and Mildew
In moist climates like ours, asphalt shingles can be prone to algae staining if not treated or maintained. We recommend algae-resistant products or regular inspections to catch these issues early. Some modern shingles, like the ones we use, have built-in protection to reduce the risk.
Temperature Sensitivity During Installation
Asphalt shingles can be tricky in extreme cold or heat. That’s why timing your installation in the right season matters. At NW Roofing and Siding Pros, we only proceed when conditions are ideal, ensuring your shingles adhere and seal properly from day one.
Asphalt Roofing Comparison: How It Measures Up
Wondering how asphalt shingles compare to other options? Let’s lay it out side-by-side.
| Roofing Type | Average Lifespan | Cost Range | Maintenance | Weight | Installation Time |
| Asphalt Shingles | 20–30 years | $8,000 – $30,000 | Low | Lightweight | Fast |
| Metal Roofing | 40–70 years | $27,000+ | Moderate | Medium | Moderate to long |
| Tile Roofing (Synthetic) | 50+ years | $50,000+ | Low | Lightweight | Moderate |
| Cedar Shake | 30 years | $75,000+ | High | Heavy | Long |
For Eugene homeowners focused on affordable roofing options, asphalt remains a strong contender. The combination of cost-effectiveness, ease of maintenance, and solid durability makes it a smart choice for many families.
How NW Roofing and Siding Pros Makes a Difference
Now that you understand the asphalt shingles pros and cons, it’s time to think about who’s putting that roof on your house. Even the best shingles can underperform if installed poorly. Here’s how NW Roofing and Siding Pros helps make sure you get the full benefit from your investment.
Certified and Trusted Installation
We’re proud to be an IKO Craftsman Premier Contractor and a Master GAF Commercial Roofing Contractor. That means we follow manufacturer standards to the letter, ensuring your warranty stays valid and your roof holds up for the long haul.
Clean Job Sites and Attention to Detail
One common fear among homeowners? Messy yards and dangerous debris after installation. We use a Catch-All system to protect your garden beds, lawn, and walkways—because we respect your home like it’s our own.
Flexible Financing and Emergency Services
Worried about the upfront cost? Through Hearth financing, we offer multiple plans to help you manage the expense of a new roof. And if weather strikes hard, we’re here 24/7 with emergency tarping and repair services.
Ready for a Roofing Upgrade? Let’s Talk
Choosing a new roof doesn’t have to feel like guesswork. If you’ve been comparing materials and are still unsure, we’re here to help you make a decision that fits your home, your budget, and your peace of mind.
Whether you’re still weighing the benefits of asphalt shingles, looking into other affordable roofing options, or ready to schedule an estimate—we’ve got you covered.
Call NW Roofing and Siding Pros at 541-935-9559 or email nwrspros@hotmail.com to schedule your free, no-pressure consultation. Let’s find out what’s best for your home—and protect what matters most.